Monday’s Top Tips – #3

Which Journal is the best to work in?

It is ONLY Monday and the week is proving to be a busy one!                                                 I will give a quick critique of the journals I bought a month ago for the Tip today.

New journals

Journal #1

This journal is approximately 6″x 9″ and has a craft cardboard cover it is made by Beci Orpin. It has manilla coloured pages which are very smooth. They took the acrylic paint quite well, but did not like things glue to them. This is the painting I completed on the first page as a trial. If I was to continue using this journal I would paint on every other page and use the pages in between strictly for journaling. I am not sure how the pages would hold up to a double-sided paint treatment. Here is my test page. (which is from an earlier post)

Rainbows – by Heather Gailey 2012

Journal #2

Canson Multi-Media Journal

This mixed media journal is made by Canson and was quite a good buy. The pages are heavy with a bit of texture. They did well with both collage elements using glue and acrylic paint. The cover is very stiff cardboard and could be painted or collaged afterwards. The only thing that worried me about this journal is that there is a perforation along the inside of the page near the coils. I suppose it is for ripping out pages you don’t like, but I would be worried about pages coming loose in the long-term. I would continue to use this sketchbook for art journaling. Here is the test painting I completed on the first page.

Hidden Feelings by Heather Gailey July 2012

Journal #3

This sketchbook did not fare so well for my test. The cover as you can see is very flimsy and mine has ripped already. It appeared at first to be plastic, but upon further investigation it is only a thin piece of shiny lightweight card stock. The paper inside is very thin and did not take paint or collage elements very well. The paper curled and the parts that were glued, buckled. I had to leave the book sitting under a heavy book over night to make it lay flat. I think this would be an ideal book for sketching or colouring, but not for anything to do with paint. Two good things that drew me originally to this particular sketchbook were the acid free paper and the size – 8″ x 8″. I would not continue to use this sketchbook for art journaling. Here is the picture I painted as a test on the first page. You can actually see the paper buckling.

Love is Power by Heather Gailey July 2012

 I haven’t told you what my fave sketchbook is to work in yet. That will have to wait until next time. Until then…what is YOUR favourite sketchbook to work in? Leave me your answer in the comments.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s